QUESTION ASKED: Why are all these IT systems failing?
CNN is reporting that the classified internal network of the National Security Agency, America’s electronic eavesdropping service, is down. This is the seventh major American system to fail in six days.
Nobody has found an attacker. Three of the failures began as routine upkeep. Edward Gibbon, the 18th-century English historian, filled six volumes of The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire and blamed barbarians and Christianity. His American successor might point toward a Windows fix and a router in El Dorado, Arkansas. Let’s briefly run through each of the failures:
1. Microsoft, November 12
Outlook email, Teams video meetings and the Copilot AI assistant went dark for about 24 hours. Microsoft’s preliminary report blames a defect in a Windows fix, a software repair installed in July. It sat unnoticed for four months. More than 80 percent of the servers that let customers into Microsoft 365, the company’s office software, stopped responding.
2. The Federal Aviation Administration, November 13
L3Harris, a defense contractor working for the FAA, which runs American air traffic control, was replacing old copper lines with fiber-optic cable at a radio site in El Dorado, Arkansas. Sean Duffy, the Transportation Secretary, called the job “pretty straightforward work.” Newly installed routers, which direct data around a network, then flooded the air traffic system with 1,000 connection attempts every four to five seconds. The FAA held every departure in the country for more than four hours, and the tracking service FlightAware counted more than 9,000 cancellations. The routers’ maker, a unit of Hewlett Packard Enterprise, says they “did not fail.” On its account they were working properly when the airspace closed.
3. Workday, November 13
Workday sells payroll and human-resources software to about 11,500 organizations. That evening many of their employees were locked out. Workday’s notice to customers said that during a test of the disaster-recovery site, the backup kept for emergencies, services there had “unexpectedly connected” to the live databases. The test of the disaster plan caused the disaster.
This list goes up to seven, by the way. It’s “All Systems Down,” Abe Greenwald writes in his Commentary newsletter:
These are trying times for an anti–conspiracy theorist.
If there’s a reason to hold off just a bit longer on the tinfoil hat, it’s this: When you look to compile a list of like events to confirm a hidden connection between them, you’ll usually find more than enough to cite as evidence. There’s a momentum to this kind of thinking. We’ve been here before in recent years.
In February 2023, the Pentagon announced that it was tracking a Chinese spy balloon over North America. This sparked a rash of additional random “balloon” sightings that briefly created the impression of an invasive swarm. In late 2024, a mixture of confirmed and unconfirmed mysterious drone sightings in New Jersey escalated until thousands of reported sightings were coming in from neighboring states. In the end, the panic arose from people who witnessed a combination of ordinary drones, conventional aircraft, and objects mistakenly identified as drones. Beginning years ago and peaking earlier this year, we had the dead and missing scientists scare. This was a viral theory purporting to connect the deaths or disappearances of a dozen or so Americans employed in the sciences. In reality, given the time frame involved, there was nothing statistically improbable about the totality of these cases.
The point is, owing to what’s known as the Baader-Meinhof phenomenon or the frequency illusion, we can be primed to notice certain phenomena that we ordinarily might ignore. Hackers are always on the job, and networks are always being breached. But we don’t usually see each incident as a piece of a larger offensive.
That being said, we’re thinking systematically about these things now because it is starting to look as if the country is under a coordinated attack.
Yasher Ali of New York magazine adds, “The frequency illusion is real… For all I know, we could learn tomorrow that a foreign adversary has launched a cyberattack, but I don’t think there’s anything wrong with pausing for a second and putting everything into context.”