QUESTION ASKED AND ANSWERED: What Was the Holdout Juror Thinking?
— Jill Filipovic, Slate, September 5th.
It’s hard to know what was in the mind of the lone holdout juror, the one who wanted to find Clancy guilty of being in her right mind when she killed her children even as he realized that the prosecution had not proved its case. I can certainly speculate: Some people want a simple story of good and evil. Some people need a punitive outcome to a horrific event, no matter actual fault or responsibility. Some people just want women punished.
Anecdotally, I’ve noticed a sharp gender divide in opinion on the Clancy case (and something of a political divide too, though a far less pronounced one). The people demanding that Clancy go to prison are overwhelmingly conservative men. Women, and especially mothers, are not cheering Clancy on but are calling largely for some nuance and care. Not every mother struggles in the postpartum period. But many of us—most of us?—have experienced the brain-and-body-altering effects of pregnancy, childbirth, and child-rearing: have felt our postbirth hormones crash, sending us reeling into despair; have felt bobbleheaded and nearly insane after weeks or months of sleepless, cry-pierced nights, pulling from some reservoir of human survival we didn’t know existed within us to meet seemingly endless needs; have been pushed into unhinged rage, then profound shame, by a defiant toddler. And then if you have more than one child, you may well be managing that defiant toddler while simultaneously experiencing the hormone crash, the sleeplessness, the bobbleheaded feeling of the newborn period all over again. Most women are not saying: “I understand why Lindsay Clancy killed her kids.” But I suspect that most of us know we don’t understand only by the grace of God or luck. Motherhood has taken many of us to new emotional planes—sometimes soaring heights, but sometimes far down into dark depths.
This far down?
This proves that the forewoman lied about the Holdout not engaging with other jurors
Nick Dargie is too dumb to understand what he just admitted https://t.co/SfysxufHKm
— Jack Posobiec (@JackPosobiec) September 10, 2026
Tweet concludes, “The holdout was reminding the room what this case actually was: three murdered children. Not a therapy session.”

