JONAH GOLDBERG: Why I Squabbled With The Bulwark.
Well, you may have heard that I got into an online spat with the folks at The Bulwark. For some fans of both publications, this felt like a tragic family squabble. For many progressives it was bizarre, akin to the People’s Front of Judea vs. the Judean People’s Front. That’s the thing about the tyranny of small differences: They aren’t small differences to the people on the inside of the conflict.
What started it was a video of Bulwark publisher Sarah Longwell at a Democratic Party conference in Colorado. She told the assembled Democrats, “You may know us, we’re the Never Trumpers. At least we were 10 years ago. Now we’re just kind of libs just like the rest of you.”
In response to the furor, Longwell tried to claim that she meant “classically liberal.” I think this was preposterous on its face. No one in that room heard that and said to themselves, “Oh, she must mean like Lord Acton or Ludwig von Mises.” And Longwell certainly didn’t think the room full of Democratic partisans was a meeting of the Mont Pelerin Society. It was spin, not an argument.
For a great many people, Longwell’s statement and her effort at damage control confirmed a widely held perspective that The Bulwark, which was founded in 2018 on the slogan that it was dedicated to “conserving conservatism,” had become more of a Democratic-aligned outlet than a, well, bulwark of conservatism.
In some cases, this isn’t really debatable. Bill Kristol, the founder of The Bulwark, has been quite candid about it.
Kristol was once a fairly passionate pro-lifer, believing the goal of the GOP should be “an America in which every unborn child is protected in law and welcomed in life.” By 2024 he was weighing in on the side of Kamala Harris to use reproductive rights as a winning wedge issue. “Let the mansplaining political commentators wring their hands. Reproductive freedom is a crucial issue, and a winning one, and the Harris campaign would be foolish not to make it a closing one in these last couple of days.”
Now, I get the argument that opposing Trump might require supporting Democrats in the House and Senate to form a check on Trump’s unified control of government. As Longwell put it in her endorsement of the anti-Israel, pro-abortion defender of all sorts of left-wing transgender priorities Abdul El-Sayed, “I will endorse candidates with whom I have big differences for the bigger picture of putting an enormous check on Donald Trump.” Though I would never dream of saying anything like what Longwell’s colleague Tim Miller did: “I could not be happier to endorse Abdul El-Sayed over the human trash that is Mike Rogers,” he said.
But if The Bulwark is about conserving conservatism, I am at a loss as to why Kristol supported Zohran Mamdani, a self-described democratic socialist and avowed anti-Zionist, in the primary against Andrew Cuomo (who is neither of those things). He’s supported Democratic governors, as well. What this has to do with opposing Trump is a mystery to me. And I am baffled why a limited-government, free-market guy would decide, after Trump was rebuked beyond anyone’s wildest dreams in the midterms, to call for a “New New Deal.”
Earlier: The Bulwark Is Uncomfortably Sailing Into the Post-Trump Era Without a Rudder. “They have become the dog that actually caught the car; once they pull their muzzle from the bumper, now what?! It is clear they intend to cast themselves with the Democratic Party lot, but in what manner could they hope to find purchase? They offer nothing unique from the massive amount of already established pro-Dem outlets.”